A peace treaty with Azerbaijan is not just a legal text. It is a strategic choice that sets Armenia’s trajectory for a decade. Below is a clear-eyed assessment of what Armenia gains with peace, the risks hidden in the fine print, and the cost of a no-deal.
1) If peace is signed: potential gains
Economy & investment
-
Lower country risk → cheaper credit and higher FDI.
-
Logistics & exports: roads/rail under Armenian sovereignty reconnect the South Caucasus with Iran, the Black Sea and Europe.
-
Tourism & services grow with safety and predictability.
-
Diaspora re-engagement: peace is the primary trigger for capital and talent to return.
Social stability
-
Household confidence rises: mortgages, SMEs, education.
-
Defense burden eases (if incidents drop), freeing budget for healthcare, schools, roads.
Institutional effects
-
Border delimitation and monitoring reduce “grey zones”.
-
POW/MIA exchanges and humanitarian mechanisms help close painful chapters.
2) Risks built into a peace deal
Execution asymmetry
-
Front-loaded benefits for the neighbor, back-loaded guarantees for Armenia.
-
Ambiguous language on Syunik/maps/inspections becomes leverage.
Domestic polarization
-
Memory of Artsakh: if legally “closed” without compensation mechanisms, society won’t accept it as just.
-
Doubt in guarantors: promises without automatic penalties are hollow.
External reactions
-
Regional pushback if clauses on corridors/observers/defense look unbalanced.
3) When peace is actually beneficial (red lines)
-
No extraterritoriality: all routes/rail under Armenian sovereignty with inspection rights.
-
Full POW/MIA exchange, dated, listed, verified.
-
Maps/coordinates as a technical annex.
-
Observers with teeth: public reporting and triggers for response.
-
Automatic consequences for breaches: project freezes, sanctions, escrow.
-
Humanitarian/compensation tools (demining, border-village funds, support for affected families).
-
Turkey symmetry: connectivity steps matched by real moves from Ankara.
4) If there is no deal: the price of status quo
Short term
-
Tense border with periodic incidents; higher defense outlays.
-
Investment pause; more expensive financing.
-
Migration pressure as families and businesses seek predictability.
Medium term
-
Economic stagnation outside Yerevan; regional decline.
-
Rising dependency on external patrons for security.
-
Unrestricted information warfare and reputational costs.
Escalation risk
-
Without channels and rules, the chance of a fatal mistake rises.
5) Government to-do list if peace is signed
-
First 24 months plan:
-
0–6 months: demining, border posts, cargo insurance, observers, POW exchange.
-
6–18 months: logistics parks, cheap power for SMEs, tourism reboot, diaspora talent campus.
-
18–24 months: export credit lines, investment-protection treaties, city concessions for water/roads/waste.
-
-
Public communication: honest trade-offs, quarterly KPIs.
-
Sovereignty shield: standing legal team for disputes; continuous clause monitoring.
6) If talks collapse — damage control
-
Hard de-escalation channels (hotline, third-party facilitation, routine border meetings).
-
Logistics pivot via Iran/Georgia + digital customs to cut costs.
-
Border focus: fortifications, ISR drones, farmer insurance, earmarked school/medical funds.
-
From survival to growth: regional tax holidays, local manufacturing of building materials and agro-processing.
7) Measuring success (public KPIs)
-
Security: incidents per 100 km, response time.
-
Economy: borrowing costs, FDI inflow, non-Yerevan jobs, exports/GDP.
-
Social: trust index, migration balance, mortgage affordability.
-
Infrastructure: km of open road/rail, average border-crossing time.
Conclusion
Peace can be Armenia’s turning point—if it strengthens sovereignty, provides enforceable guarantees, and kick-starts growth. Peace without safeguards becomes an asymmetry trap.
No deal removes the “paper risks” but multiplies war risks.
The real choice is between managed risks and unmanaged ones.
New leadership must turn the former into a national opportunity.
By Lida Nalbandyan, Founder and CEO of Octopus Media Group